From the China Rises blog by Tim Johnson (via HaoHao)
Here is what you don’t see in China: You don’t see enraged passengers reaching across airline counters and shaking fingers at quivering airline employees. You don’t see people drinking way too much on flights and making scenes. In other words, you don’t see behavior that goes beyond boorish to the realms of freakish and even dangerous.
In China, I never look around and hope there’s an air marshal nearby.
I got an email from a reader in Massachusetts recently voicing surprise at the lack of road rage in China. It’s true. There’s plenty of muttering among drivers, and an occasional shout. But I never see drivers, pedestrians or cyclists really lose it. Just about everywhere else outside of Asia, I’ve seen that.
First things first, in China I have seen an enraged passenger of an airline yell at an airline employee at a check in counter, step up onto the conveyor belt that pulls luggage into the the metal detector and pick up and slam on the floor some piece of machinery from the desk (possibly the credit card swiper?). I have seen people screaming at each other from their cars, and was in a cab for an epic shouting match between a man on a bike and our female cab driver. Of course, these incidents are relatively rare, and Tim Johnson’s not seeing it and my witnessing of it proves nothing. But that is my point; to say that there is no road rage in China is a ridiculous statement for many reasons. He cites no studies, articles, or other opinion pieces that support his findings. Johnson also makes no attempt to explain his theory, or to give reason as to why there is this lack of the phenomenon.
However, my own personal experiences, my discussions with others, articles I have read (Road Rage, Chinese Style), and even the comments for that post on his blog directly contradict his point that these public outbursts of anger are non existent. I find China Rises to generally be a good blog, but this post just seemed so wrong I needed to address it.
Popularity: 24% [?]

I think road rage is still common at least in Shanghai, however the difference perhaps between Shanghai and Massachusetts is that when an American sees a fight, they generally avert their eyes for fear of the dreaded “What are YOU lookin’ at?” from the guy with the reddest face, and the Metallica T-Shirt. In Shanghai, whenever there is prang or a near miss, any harsh words exchanged quickly turns into a public Shanghainese pantomime “Oh no you didn’t!, Oooooh yes you did!”
With this kind of attention for any public outburst, it’s difficult to reach into the glove box to get the 9mm and offload your anger into your fellow road warrior.
trust me, I’ve seen Chinese road rage… the difference is that it does not escalate into anything more than a few choice Chinese curse words…. Unless both drivers happen to be Shanghainese women.
Comment by dedlam — September 22, 2008 @ 9:05 am
[…] Washington Posts’ China Rises blog notes Chinese drivers have a refreshing lack of road rage. Not so fast, says another blogger. [China Rises and […]
Pingback by China Journal : Best of the China Blogs: Sept. 22 — September 22, 2008 @ 12:04 pm